Austin Chapter
Reader's Guide
April 2005
The Opposite of Fate
Amy Tan
Amy Tan has touched millions of readers with haunting and sympathetic novels of cultural complexity and profound empathy. With the same spirit and humor that characterize her acclaimed novels, she now shares her insight into her own life and how she escaped the curses of her past to make a future of her own...
(Questions taken from of www.penguinputnam.com/static/rguides/us/opposite_of_fate.html)
- Do you believe in fate? How would you define it? Can you personally relate somehow to the ways that various individuals in this collection confronted fate?
- Why do you think that with all of the adventures, trials and plights the author faced, she chose to end the book with a discussion on her battle with Lyme disease? How does this particular piece encapsulate the major themes discussed in the book?
- Which piece of writing in The Opposite of Fate did you find to be most enjoyable.i.e., the most thought provoking or personally influential? Share your thoughts with the group.
- Discuss some of the "alternatives" to fate that Amy Tan lists in her note to the reader. How do they manifest themselves in the various pieces in The Opposite of Fate?
- Focus on the piece entitled "A Question of Fate," wherein the author tells of the uncanny premonition she had regarding the murder of a friend. What role do dreams and the subconscious play in a discussion of fate?
- Discuss the significance of the author's Chinese heritage and upbringing in relation to the larger themes in the book. Do you think that her particular ancestry lends itself more readily to an appreciation of fate? Why or why not?
- Throughout this compilation, the notions of loss and inexplicable tragedy are ever-present. How effective do you think writing is as a means to ease emotional and psychological pain?
- Did any one individual in this book affect you more than others? What was it about their story that influenced you?
- Revisit the selection entitled "scent". How do you think this passage fits in to a compilation of writing on fate? How is it reflective of the rest of the collection?
- Delve a bit into the life of Daisy Tan (Amy's mother). How would you describe the relationship between mother and daughter? Discuss some examples of Tan's mother attempting to change fate. How did they affect her daughter's life, either directly or indirectly?
The Story Circle Network is a national not-for-profit membership organization made up of women who want to explore their lives and their souls by exploring their personal stories. If you would like to learn more about the Network and its activities, please sign up for our free email newsletters!
