Story Circle Network
Internet Chapter
Reader's Guide


with a woman's voice: a writer's struggle for emotional freedom
by Lucy Daniels

With a Woman's Voice by Lucy Daniels is a many-layered collage of stories collectively unraveling the mystery manifested in her anorexia. Lucy Daniels includes childhood vignettes tangled with US history; insights into mental hospital culture; love stories; dream analyses; and chronicles of an evolving writer. You will feel you know Lucy well by the closing chapter. It may take a while longer to discern where your sympathies lie regarding her significant relationships.

Discussion Questions:

  1. Lucy struggled with femininity. How did this both help and inhibit her as a writer?

  2. Does the contrast in formality of Lucy's name for her parents influence her relationship with "Mommy" vs. "Father"?

  3. How did Mommy influence Lucy's self image? How did Father influence Lucy's self image?

  4. Which of the doctor episodes gave you a sense of hope?

  5. How did Lucy's problem with her eyes influence her life?

  6. Besides Mommy and Father, who in Lucy's family hurt her significantly?

  7. Father asserted that Lucy was unfeeling, his "boy", and selfish. Was he observing or assigning these qualities?

  8. Did use of dream interpretations enhance the unveiling of Lucy's psychoanalysis?

  9. Did Mommy's dimple remind you of a physical characteristic in one of your parents?

  10. How did Mommy's rules compare to authority in your childhood?

  11. By the time you finish the book, do you feel Daniels really wrote a trilogy inside one set of covers? (change in tone from childhood chapters to hospital chapters to the last several chapters)


Last updated: 02/10/03